Definetely mac, 
It is great quality, all their blushes, bronzers, lip products , eye-shadows are VERY pigmented 
Their eyeshaDefinetely macintosh, 
It is nice quality, all their blushes, bronzers, lip product , eye-shadows area unit terribly pigmented 
Their eyeshadows area unit terribly soft and not too onerous on your skin. 
Their mascaras build your eyelashes look pretend (in a decent way) 
Their brushes area unit soft, and that they last long! 
And i additionally reccomend giving a glance at their "seasonal" things, they invariably come back up with new restricted lines like their "hey, saylor" or the "Marylin Monroe" assortment and currently have their vacation line offered purchasable. 
The only things that i'm not terribly affected with area unit their foundations. Personally, I even have had no issues with them, however a number of my firends told Maine the inspiration created them run off. 
So, that's a warning. dows are very soft and not too hard on your skin. 
Their mascaras make your eyelashes look fake (in a good way) 
Their brushes are soft, and they last long! 
And i also reccomend giving a look at their "seasonal" items, they always come up with new limited lines like their "hey, saylor" or the "Marylin Monroe" collection and now have their Holiday line available for sale. 
The only things that i am not very impressed with are their foundations. Personally, i have had no problems with them, but some of my firends told me the foundation made them break out. 
So, that is a warning. 

But overall, i think you should choose mac! 
Great quality, even though their products are a bit of a splurge! 
hope this helped!